Murder mystery parties are a captivating blend of storytelling, problem-solving, and immersive fun. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting a themed dinner, or simply seeking a unique way to gather friends, a well-planned murder mystery guarantees an evening of laughter, suspense, and excitement.
Table of contents
Not sure where to start? Here’s everything you need to know to create an unforgettable murder mystery party!
1. Choosing the perfect theme
The theme sets the stage for your murder mystery party, influencing everything from decor and costumes to dialogue and atmosphere.
Here are four popular options:
70s disco fever
Dust off your bell-bottoms and step into a world of funky music, platform shoes, and high-stakes drama. Set in a dazzling disco club, Mystery at the Groove Gala is packed with scandal, dancefloor rivalries, and a shocking crime that disrupts the groove. Guests can channel their inner diva, rock flashy outfits, and try to solve the mystery before the party's over!
80s throwback thriller
Neon lights, leg warmers, and a whole lot of hairspray set the scene for this totally rad mystery. In Death on the Dance Floor, guests step into Eclipse 54, an exclusive nightclub where secrets, scandals, and deadly rivalries threaten to shake the dancefloor. Can you crack the case before the final beat drops?
Death on the Dance Floor is suitable for 8-18 guests. Death on the Dance Floor is adapted from Mystery at the Groove Gala. If you’ve played one, do not purchase the other.
Casino crime night
Glamorous evening wear, high-rolling gamblers, and a dramatic betrayal make Vegas Vendetta a thrilling choice. Set in the legendary Diamond Dollar Casino, guests play as cunning card sharks, suspicious lounge singers, or high-stakes gamblers navigating a world where fortunes are made – and someone won’t make it out alive.
1920s speakeasy mystery
The Roaring Twenties, with its clandestine speakeasies, jazz music, and flapper fashion, offers a rich backdrop for a murder mystery. While we don't currently offer a kit for this theme, it's a classic choice that many hosts adore. Keep an eye out – My Mystery Kit is working on an exciting new 1920s mystery kit coming soon! In the meantime, there are plenty of great options already available on the market for this theme.
Our pre-made mystery kits simplify theme planning by providing everything you need – character profiles, objectives, evidence, speeches, curated playlists, and even Amazon wish lists for theme-perfect accessories!
2. Planning and preparation
A seamless murder mystery night requires solid planning, but that doesn’t mean it has to be difficult.
Pre-made kit vs. DIY
Some hosts consider creating their own mystery, but DIY games can be incredibly time-consuming – you’ll need to write a compelling script, develop character backstories, create evidence, and ensure the game flows smoothly.
That’s why we highly recommend using a professionally designed kit. Our kits include:
- Character assignments tailored to your guest list (no awkward role mismatches!)
- 4-5 pieces of evidence revealed in waves throughout the night
- A welcome speech, detective speech and final solution readout to keep structure
- 3 awards for best performer, best detective and best dressed
- Themed Spotify playlists to match the era and enhance the atmosphere
- Amazon wish lists for decor and props so you don’t have to hunt for supplies
Plus, a bunch more. With everything included, you can focus on having fun instead of stressing over party planning details.
Assigning characters & customization
Character assignment can make or break your murder mystery experience. Our kits are customized to match your guest list, ensuring each player has a role that fits. Plus, our character assignment guides makes it easy to distribute roles based on group size (see example).
Setting the scene
We strongly recommend hosting at home for comfort and flexibility. Unless it’s a corporate event or large gathering, your home provides the perfect relaxed setting.
- Decor tips: Transform your space using simple but effective props. Think disco balls for a 70s party, neon signs for an 80s throwback, or poker tables for a casino night.
- Lighting & music: Use dim lighting, candles, or LED strips to set the mood. Our kits include a curated playlist to enhance the atmosphere.
Check out this example from a customer who used lighting to create an immersive 70s murder mystery experience:
Food & drinks
Themed food elevates the experience!
Consider:
- Disco snacks: Cheese balls (resembling disco balls), deviled eggs (dubbed "Dig It Devils"), or a disco ball charcuterie are fun options. For more ideas, check out these 70s disco party food suggestions.
- 80s throwback bites: Potato skins, mini quiches, and 7-layer dip were popular in the 80s. Explore more 80s party food ideas.
- Casino night hors d’oeuvres: Stuffed mushrooms, shrimp cocktails, and martinis add a touch of elegance.
- 1920s speakeasy drinks: Classic cocktails like Old Fashioneds, Sidecars, and prohibition-style punch set the mood. For authentic recipes, visit these 1920s party food and drink ideas.
For those incorporating a sit-down meal, check out our guide: How to host a murder mystery dinner party.
3. Immersive details to elevate the experience
Small touches turn a fun party into an unforgettable event.
- Evidence revealed in waves: Our kits include multiple evidence pieces that are introduced throughout the night, keeping the suspense alive.
- Curated playlists: No need to spend hours searching for the right tunes – each of our kits includes a playlist tailored to the theme.
- Themed invitations: Send out invitations that match your theme to set the tone from the start.
4. Hosting tips for a smooth experience
Even first-time hosts can run a seamless murder mystery with the right approach.
- Prepping guests: Each kit includes a structured welcome speech to set expectations and immerse players right away.
- Guiding the game: Use the included detective speech and final solution readout to keep things moving smoothly.
- Encouraging role-playing: If some guests are hesitant, gently nudge them into character by asking in-game questions.
- Managing surprises: Players may improvise – embrace it! The evidence reveals help guide the story without requiring strict adherence to a script.
5. Conclusion
Hosting a murder mystery party is a fantastic way to engage friends and family in an unforgettable night of intrigue. With a well-chosen theme, immersive details, and structured hosting, your event is sure to be a hit. If you’re new to this type of party, here’s a great breakdown of how murder mystery parties actually work – from setup to solving the crime. Using a pre-made kit ensures a smooth, stress-free experience so you can focus on having fun.
Ready to plan your perfect murder mystery party? Pick your theme and let the mystery unfold!
